Movie review by Greg Carlson
I admit to having a soft spot for movies that eventually transform into swans of the cult-following variety after languishing as box office and/or critical ugly ducklings. Despite affection for witchy tales and the presence of two appealing future Oscar-winners in major roles (not to mention the incredible Dianne Wiest, already an Academy Award-winner, in support), the original 1998 “Practical Magic” was not my cup of herbal tea. I am happy, though, that it found dedicated defenders. I also have a fascination with long-delayed sequels (“The Color of Money,” “Blade Runner 2049,” “Top Gun: Maverick” and “Beetlejuice Beetlejuice,” for example) because it is such strange and delightful fun to catch up with old friends and imagine what they have been doing for all those years.
In the case of “Practical Magic 2,” based on the 2021 Alice Hoffman novel “The Book of Magic,” the dreaded curse suffered by generations of Owens family witches continues to vex the offspring of Sandra Bullock’s Sally, who has made sister Gillian (Nicole Kidman) promise not to tell Sally’s daughters Kylie and Antonia (now played by Joey King and Maisie Williams) anything about their magical heritage. Kylie has fallen in love with Gideon (Xolo Maridueña), setting up the plot that will hinge on a trip from New England to Old England. Sally and Gillian, realizing the grave danger awaiting Kylie, follow the young woman, soon crossing paths with occult historian Ian Wright (Lee Pace).
It would be fair as well as easy to take the production to task for essentially erasing the happy ending of Griffin Dunne’s original, a common sequel tactic that gathers like a storm cloud (I hated learning that Ali left Daniel for a football player at the outset of “The Karate Kid Part II,” to name one similar instance). Director Susanne Bier senses the limitations of the source enough to emphasize the stuff that most appeals to the fanbase. Leaning heavily into the themes of ride-or-die sisterhood, Bier makes lots of space for Bullock and Kidman to perfect a Laurel and Hardy routine that snips some of the slapstick but retains the light bickering and underlying affection of Stan and Oliver.
Seeing the two big stars share the screen will be enough for some devotees, but “Practical Magic 2” should have applied more hocus pocus before we get to the special effects-heavy showdown at the climax. Why is there a running gag in which the sisters struggle up multiple flights with heavy roller bags when a simple spell could have levitated the burden? Once the sisters meet Pace’s tattoo-covered mystery man, the comic hijinks temporarily shift to a bizarre triangle abetted by Gillian’s matchmaking encouragement. Bullock and Kidman retain their camaraderie and chemistry, even if Sally takes center stage while Gillian is shifted off to the side.
Sequels like “Practical Magic 2” are expected to be cinematic comfort food, a recipe dependent on the reuse of many of the ingredients that viewers love in the originals. Besides the presence of additional Stevie Nicks on the soundtrack, Bier might have erred too much on reprise, since the deathwatch beetle, the mixing of midnight margaritas to Nilsson’s “Coconut,” and the rooftop umbrella descent all reappear. Alongside that nostalgia is something akin to a passing of the torch (hail to Wiest and Stockard Channing!), as Sally and Gillian recognize their ascendancy to senior status in the Owens matriarchy. They are the aunts now.









