The French Dispatch of the Liberty, Kansas Evening Sun

HPR French Dispatch (2021)

Movie review by Greg Carlson

First, a note to the naysayers and cynics and grumps and sourpusses and killjoys who would dismiss Wes Anderson as a suffocating ironist infatuated with his dollhouse miniatures and his own cookie cutter formulae recycling the same set of actors within his symmetrically composed frames: GET LOST, GO AWAY, SHOVE OFF. “The French Dispatch of the Liberty, Kansas Evening Sun” is not for you. But for those who have maintained punctuality and perfect attendance, those who have ever substituted a Tic Tac for prescription stomach cancer medication, those who keep dues paid-up in the Society of the Crossed Keys, you don’t need me or anybody else to tell you that the enchantments to be found in Ennui-sur-Blasé provide the exact opposite of boredom-on-apathy.

Anderson’s longtime affection for “The New Yorker” gives “The French Dispatch” its structure, its themes, and its emotional core. Bill Murray’s Harold Ross-esque Arthur Howitzer, Jr., the scion of a newspaper publisher, presides over the magazine produced from his adopted home in France. The conclusion of Howitzer’s spectacular half-century run as editor-in-chief results in the dramatization of the final issue of “The French Dispatch,” broken into a prologue, three stories, and an obituary. While any of the individual segments could have evolved into feature length, Anderson takes complete advantage of the creative form of the omnibus to configure a coherent and cohesive whole.

“Bottle Rocket,” of course, was a short before it was a feature. And “Hotel Chevalier” and “Castello Cavalcanti,” along with several promotional films and advertisements, point toward Anderson’s interest in experimentation beyond the cinephile’s acknowledged admiration of anthology films like De Sica’s “The Gold of Naples” and Max Ophüls’s “Le Plaisir.” The director’s adherents will spend hours parsing the long-delayed movie’s chapters, debating favorites and identifying cross-pollination. One dreams of a companion glossary similar to the reference guide contained on Criterion’s “Band of Outsiders” disc to identify all the specific literary and cinematic allusions.

Each section offers up an array of Anderson’s giddy passions, in both text and subtext. Owen Wilson, as Herbsaint Sazerac, invites us to the party via “The Cycling Reporter,” a gliding, velocipede-mounted travelogue highlighting the love and squalor of Ennui’s past and future, with special focus on the dregs, the destitute, and the failures, not to mention marauding choirboys half-drunk on the Blood of Christ. In “The Concrete Masterpiece,” Tilda Swinton’s J. K. L. Berensen expands on Anderson’s established contemplation of incarceration — both spiritual and material — in a deeply satisfying tale based in part on S. N. Berhman’s 1951 profile of art dealer Joseph Duveen.

Frances McDormand portrays Lucinda Krementz in “Revisions to a Manifesto,” inspired by Mavis Gallant’s observations on the May, 1968 civil unrest in Paris. Krementz and Léa Seydoux’s prison guard Simone mark significant strides toward greater depth, richness, and significance than Anderson has, with few exceptions, previously shown to women. In “The Private Dining Room of the Police Commissioner” by Jeffrey Wright’s Roebuck Wright (a mashup of James Baldwin and A. J. Liebling), the author recounts with perfect typographic memory a sprawling and sumptuous kidnapping yarn while being interviewed on a talk show.

Wright, working for the first time with Anderson, fits right in alongside the veteran troupe members. A number of critics have bristled at the way in which “The French Dispatch” relegates top-flight talent, like Willem Dafoe, Saoirse Ronan, Edward Norton, and several others, to near-cameo status, but I don’t mind seeing Anderson alumni (Bob Balaban! Larry Pine! Tony Revolori!) populate the cast the way that Hitchcock frequently plugged in Leo G. Carroll or David Lynch counted on Frances Bay. And even though she is not currently listed among the performers set to appear in Anderson’s “Asteroid City,” I will keep my fingers crossed that Elisabeth Moss will be back for more.

Like the very best of Wes Anderson, “The French Dispatch” is large and contains multitudes. The autobiographical touches, expressed by the ensemble of fictional expatriates and natives alike, are as bewitching as the director’s exuberant application of physical set pieces, period design, shifts between color and monochrome, changing aspect ratios, animation, self-reflexive stage plays, breathless cutaways, snap-zooms and on-the-fly reframings, onscreen graphics, leaps in time, living dioramas, and the dazzling marriage of images and words. The earnest and the parodic coexist as comfortably as the close proximity of humor and sorrow. It should go without saying that “The French Dispatch” requires multiple viewings to unlock its generous and special secrets.

Dune

HPR Dune 2 (2021)

Movie review by Greg Carlson

The many media attempts at Frank Herbert’s epic space fantasy “Dune” speak to its lasting appeal and its potent impact. David Lynch’s movie, defended by the filmmaker’s most ardent supporters but excoriated by a larger chorus disappointed in the heavy hand applied by House De Laurentiis, marked the end of a lengthy journey to the screen that defeated the likes of Alejandro Jodorowsky and Ridley Scott along the way. Dreams of what might have been — Orson Welles as Baron Harkonnen! Moebius and H. R. Giger design! — gave way to the realities of any “faithful” adaptation. At its best, Herbert’s book presents a stunning vision of political power, ecological and environmental awareness, ruling-class genealogy, military conflict, and thrilling mysticism and religious mythmaking filtered through a messianic hero’s journey.

At its weakest, “Dune” has too many scenes of people standing around and talking.

Denis Villeneuve’s “Dune: Part One” is a worthy addition to the collection, besting the Lynch in certain ways but still flummoxed and frustrated by the source material’s conversation-heavy downside. Villeneuve is clearly a fan, a Bene Gesserit-level adherent to the Weirding Way and a desert mouse who respects the Shai-Hulud. The director’s impressive track record with dazzling ideas and/or imagery in settings both smaller (“Prisoners,” “Enemy”) and grander (“Arrival,” “Blade Runner 2049”) raised expectations higher than a Guild Navigator on uncut spice. The filmmaker delivers at least 450 meters of world-building eye candy to remind everyone of Herbert’s far-reaching influence.

Villeneuve juggles a huge cast filled with famous and should-be famous performers well-suited to flesh out their occasionally flat literary antecedents. Some great faces made up Lynch’s roster, including many favorites in the filmmaker’s stock company, and Villeneuve could not ask for more capable portrayers in nearly all the principal and supporting roles. Rebecca Ferguson as Jessica and Oscar Isaac as Duke Leto Atreides, despite sharing few one-on-one scenes, walk off with the movie. While Lynch’s screenplay diminished and truncated Jurgen Prochnow’s Leto, Villeneuve concentrates the time and attention required to express the Shakespearean tragedy of the Red Duke and articulate the emotional connection between Leto and his son.

Perhaps Jodorowsky was on to something when he argued for a ten to fourteen-hour running time. If all goes according to plan, “Dune: Part Two” will remedy the insufficient, almost fleeting presence of Zendaya’s Chani, Javier Bardem’s Stilgar, and even Dave Bautista’s Beast Rabban. There’s no question that Villeneuve’s decision to divide the book leaves both newcomers and the “Dune” faithful with lots of questions and the empty feelings that go along with unfinished business. My friend Aaron Anderson is spot-on with his note that the second section should have been filmed at the same time and prepared for a 2022 release.

Villeneuve’s “Dune” takes itself so seriously that plenty of observers have dipped their Gom Jabbar needles into poisoned inkwells. David Ehrlich’s vicious takedown is entertainingly arch, slightly cruel, and not entirely fair. Peter Opaskar’s wild, tongue-in-cheek defense of Lynch’s version as the greatest film ever made — one of several recent reassessments of the 1984 movie — was posted before Opaskar watched the new one. I am glad to live in a world where we already have two big screen interpretations and Frank Pavitch’s fantastic documentary. If we don’t destroy ourselves, there will surely be enough “Dune” by the year 10,191 to please everybody.

Golden Arm

HPR Golden Arm (1)

Movie review by Greg Carlson

Maureen Bharoocha’s “Golden Arm” applies the irresistible combination of long-haul trucking and competitive arm wrestling in the tradition of Menahem Golan’s 1987 Sylvester Stallone cult nugget “Over the Top.” Close friendship replaces father-son bonding as the emotional heartbeat of the story, and Bharoocha, working from a very funny screenplay by Ann Marie Allison and Jenna Milly, capitalizes on the opportunity to imagine a cartoonish subculture grounded in pathos. Originally programmed as part of the canceled 2020 South by Southwest festival, “Golden Arm” had to settle for a small theatrical run and an April 2021 arrival on-demand. As a result, the film has received less love and attention than it deserves.

Television comedy and Upright Citizens Brigade veteran Mary Holland is Melanie, an about-to-be-divorced baker struggling to make a success of her profession. Truck-driving best friend Danny, played by fellow UCB alum Betsy Sodaro, convinces Mel to close up shop for a few days and join her on a delivery. Bharoocha rockets through basic exposition on the way to revealing Danny’s real plan: enter Mel into the arm wrestling nationals being held in Oklahoma City. The purse is fifteen grand, but the bigger prize is an opportunity for the pals to rebuild the tight bonds of their younger days.

Naturally, the cautious, vanilla Mel (who blanches at Danny’s liberal use of descriptive profanity, especially a certain term applied to genitalia) initially resists the call to step up, but Danny’s powers of persuasion and the desperation to collect the handsome winnings convince her otherwise. Unable to compete, Danny’s own wrestling arm is wrapped up in a brace, which adds another layer of pressure. Bharoocha seizes on the script’s episodic structure to explore multiple genres; “Golden Arm” works as both a road movie and as a tournament/elimination-style sports contest, but the relationship of Mel and Danny always sits squarely at the heart of the film.

Bharoocha also manages a colorful gallery of supporting characters, each of whom adds to the circus. Revealing a steady hand and deft touch for romance, the director nails the scenes shared by Holland and Eugene Cordero, who plays referee Greg. The dialogue anticipating their flirtatious magic hour kiss against the chain link fence at a baseball diamond is one of the year’s sexiest screen conversations. De rigueur training montages get an assist from Dot-Marie Jones. Olivia Stambouliah’s Brenda the Bone Crusher, Mel and Danny’s bête noire, is a delightfully hissable nemesis (so many of the arm wrestling personae boast sweet monikers). Ron Funches as organizer Carl, Danny’s friends-with-benefits hookup, is as wonderfully awkward as Ahmed Bharoocha’s Jerry, who serves as Danny’s personal gofer and Swiss Army knife.

It is not difficult to picture a studio-backed “Golden Arm” with a bigger budget and the likes of Kristen Wiig as Mel and Melissa McCarthy as Danny, but the scrappier and scruffier version that got made is somehow more perfect because of its limitations and rough edges. Holland and Sodaro are so effortlessly good together, their characters evoking the kind of visual contrast unforgettably rendered by Stan Laurel and Oliver Hardy, that they deserve every bit as much recognition as better known A-list comics. The scene-stealing Sodaro’s work as the lusty, foul-mouthed, wrecking-ball extrovert is equal to the best of Jack Black and Zach Galifianakis.

Collecting Movies with Anthony Strand

CM with AS 5 (2021)

Interview by Greg Carlson

Before she introduced us, mutual friend Morgan Davy told me that Anthony Strand had the uncanny ability to remember the exact running time of every movie he had seen. And he has seen a lot of movies.

Strand was born in 1984, under the sign of “Amadeus,” “This Is Spinal Tap,” and “The Muppets Take Manhattan.” He currently lives in Roseville, Minnesota, with his wife Rosalynn and their two children. He is a school librarian in Farmington, Minnesota, where he enthusiastically hosts the morning announcements.

 

Greg Carlson: My mom took me to “Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs.” What was your first theatrical screening?

Anthony Strand: My first movie in the theatre was also a Disney reissue. I saw “The Jungle Book” in 1988. Twenty-one years following the film’s original release. That thing Disney used to do where it was every seven years. So I got in on the tail end of that tradition.

 

GC: When you go to see a movie at a very young age, some kinds of memories might stand out more than a full grasp of the film itself. Getting popcorn or the lobby of the theatre might leave as big an impression as any fear of the Evil Queen disguised as an old crone or any fascination with the Magic Mirror.

AS: My brother just gave me the VHS of “We’re Back! A Dinosaur’s Story.” It’s not a good movie, but I was 8 years old when it came out. And we watched it so many times. I hadn’t looked at it in probably 25 years and the only thing that was familiar was the big John Goodman musical number by Thomas Dolby and James Horner.

There’s a scene in the movie where a little girl wishes for a Thanksgiving hat. And I have such a distinct memory as a kid believing that a Thanksgiving hat was an actual thing.

 

GC: Where did you grow up?

AS: I grew up in Hatton, North Dakota. There was a local video store, the Hatton Pharmacy, that became a little general store. That place was huge for me. The owner, Sutin Sorowat, was our neighbor across the alley. He would talk to me about the movies on his shelves. Stuff I had seen and stuff I had not seen.

Sutin had the Columbia House Collector’s Edition VHS volumes of “All in the Family.” I rented every one of those tapes when I was 12 and 13. And that show became one of my favorite things to watch.

 

GC: So many cinephiles have that intellectual curiosity combined with a voracious appetite to consume content. And especially things that were made before you were born.

AS: I was always into old sitcoms. When I was in sixth grade, I kept a set of tabbed file folders so I could write down information like the network, the number of episodes, and what years a series aired.

 

GC: Where were you getting that information?

AS: Two of my most treasured items were “Total Television” by Alex McNeil and “The Complete Directory to Prime Time Network and Cable TV Shows 1946-Present” by Tim Brooks and Earle Marsh. I read both from cover to cover and of course put a star by everything that I had seen. After those two books I soon acquired an edition of Leonard Maltin’s Movie Guide.

 

GC: Once the Maltin book was updated and issued every year, my mentor Ted Larson would circle the street date and turn it into an event. I would often accompany him to the bookstore where he purchased three or four copies — one for the office at school, one for the projection booth in Weld Hall, one for home, etc. 

Eventually, I was also buying the new edition every year and would also go through and mark the films I had seen.

AS: I think the last Maltin I picked up was 2002, when I was a senior in high school. Specifically with that one, I decided to go through it and write down a list of movies that I thought I should see. I got a little green notebook and started copying over titles. I only made it to G before I had to stop.

 

GC: Was your to-see list based on the star ratings?

AS: Yes, but I did take some of them with a grain of salt.

 

GC: How dare Maltin give “Taxi Driver” only two stars!

AS: So funny that “Taxi Driver” is the one Maltin review that always comes up. It is burned into my brain that he describes the film as “ugly and unredeeming.”

CM with AS 1 (2021)

GC: Well, I still think it is a masterpiece. But you were more into comedy.

AS: The real gateway for my interest in classic movies was the Marx Brothers.

 

GC: How did you find your way to them?

AS: I watched the Three Stooges with my dad and my brothers every week. As a sixth grader, I wore my Three Stooges t-shirt on the first day of school. Carefully chosen. “This is who I am.” The year is 1996.

For Christmas, my grandma, perhaps misunderstanding or misremembering, got me a hardcover book about the Marx Brothers, a comedy team I had never seen and had no experience with. I thought, “I don’t know what this is, but I will look into it.” It was a slim hardcover called “Marx Brothers” by Kate Stables and I must have read it a thousand times. It has a picture from “Duck Soup” on the cover with the four brothers in their military uniforms.

I had not seen any Marx Brothers films yet but I thought, “This sounds great! I need to see this stuff.” So the “wrong” book turned out to be exactly the right book. I checked “Duck Soup” out of the Grand Forks Public Library and I loved it. It is my favorite movie to this day.

Not long after, I bought “A Night at the Opera” and “A Day at the Races” on VHS at Suncoast Motion Picture Company. What a world! A person could walk into the Columbia Mall in Grand Forks, North Dakota, and buy “Horse Feathers” and take it home. Incredible!

 

GC: My grandpa got me hooked on Humphrey Bogart. Our goal was to collect as many Bogart movies as we could find. As a fairly early adopter of VHS, my grandpa owned several decks and we would attempt to dub copies of movies we rented from Videoland as well as record features from broadcast and cable. I still cherish the tapes with my grandpa’s hand-written labels.

AS: I love that. I bought the first seven Marx Brothers movies, but I had “Room Service” recorded from AMC. That was the one Marx Brothers movie that I taped from TV. So my interest in the Marx Brothers was the start, but two things also happened around the same time. I got my first DVD player with my own paper route money at the age of 14. And the debut in June, 1998 of AFI’s 100 Years … 100 Movies on CBS. I decided to see all 100 of the movies on the AFI list. It took me a while, but I eventually did it. I managed to see all but one before I graduated from high school.

 

GC: I have to know, what was the last one?

AS: “Midnight Cowboy.” It was when I decided to watch every Best Picture winner that I saved “Midnight Cowboy” for last so I could finish both lists at the same time.

 

GC: No matter how many movies or TV shows you have seen, the joy of checking off titles can be satisfying.

AS: Even though I saw “The Naked Gun” first, I loved “Police Squad!” I rented those tapes from Videos Plus Pizza & Subs in Mayville, North Dakota. In one of the television books, there was a description of “Sledge Hammer!” claiming it was in the vein of “Police Squad!” I had never seen “Sledge Hammer!,” which ran for two seasons on ABC. The show was long gone by the time I was first learning about its existence. So for years, I longed to see “Sledge Hammer!”

Then the TV on DVD boom happened. I bought both seasons of “Sledge Hammer!” because I had spent all that time building it up in my mind. I kept thinking, “What if these 41 episodes are like more “Police Squad!” shows?” And it is not quite that. It is a more conventional satirical sitcom. But I enjoyed it.

 

GC: Will you abandon a show if it does not meet your standards?

AS: I do now, but not so much then. The older I get, the less patience I have for so-called prestige television, which doesn’t appeal to me. There are exceptions, of course. I watched all of “The Wire,” and it is brilliant.

CM with AS 4 (2021)

GC: Making viewing choices can be torturous. I am always prioritizing between newly-released films and classic cinema that I have not previously viewed while still making room for key re-watches. I just saw “The Two Mrs. Carrolls” for the first time this year and I loved it.

AS: What is the Bogart movie where he discovers the cafe is a front for Nazis?

 

GC: “All Through the Night.”

AS: Remind me, is his best friend William Frawley?

 

GC: William Demarest.

AS: Right! I knew it was a grandpa or uncle from “My Three Sons.” “All Through the Night” was the last new-to-me Bogart movie that I saw and wondered why hardly anyone talks about it. With a title like “All Through the Night,” you can understand why I couldn’t remember the name of the movie.

 

GC: I love it when you find a semi-forgotten gem, fall in love, and then recommend it to everyone. You end up associating certain films with the friends who champion them. Every year on Ben Hanson’s birthday, I post the loop of Sam Neill saying, “The lies!” from “Possession.” 

AS: And yet I associate Ben Hanson with “Legend,” because he bought my DVD copy when I decided to let it go. I know “Legend” isn’t Ben’s favorite movie, but anytime it comes up I am reminded of him.

 

GC: One might think Ben’s favorite movie is “Airplane!,” but I believe it is “Brazil.”

AS: Makes sense. The three-disc Criterion set of “Brazil” was one of my high school staples. The television cut with the happy ending is fascinating. Profanity edited out. You know, “Give me the keys, you fairy godmother” kind of stuff. And it’s 94 minutes long. As long as we’re talking about physical media, I appreciate the way the Criterion has an enthusiastic presentation of a cut that asks, “What if this movie was bad? Well, here it is, preserved in amber.”

 

GC: More television cuts should be included as bonus content. I am still drooling over Criterion’s “Fast Times at Ridgemont High,” which contains the television edit of the film. That alone makes it worth the price.

AS: “The Jerk” is another one that always comes to mind. Steve Martin’s dog is named Shithead, but in the TV version the dog is called Stupid.

CM with AS 3 (2021)

GC: As a parent of young children, what kind of content do you share with your kids?

AS: My daughter Iris is six and my son Miles is three. We watch a lot of old “Sesame Street.” Iris especially loves Looney Tunes and Merrie Melodies. Iris and I have been working on a project to view every Best Animated Short in order. We haven’t gotten to all of them and are up to 1960 or so.

What has been fun for me is to see her discover new things. She already knew Tom and Jerry. They had too many wins — seven to just one Bugs Bunny. That ratio should be flipped. But she didn’t know Mister Magoo. And she was not into it. But both my kids went bananas for the Yugoslav cartoon “Surogat,” which is known in English as “Ersatz” or “The Substitute.” Watched it three times in a row.

 

GC: What is the story behind your interest in “Eliminators”? I have never seen it.

AS: It’s from Charles Band’s legendary Full Moon Features. One of the great schlock VHS houses at its peak in the 1990s. They cranked out tons of direct-to-video sci-fi and horror. I am not a huge horror guy once you get past Hammer, but my brothers and I loved Full Moon’s sci-fi offerings. There’s something about them, you know?

The director of “Eliminators” is a guy named Peter Manoogian. And he made a lot of movies that are almost incompetent but compulsively watchable. We say the lines with irony, but we have also seen all these movies many times. “Eliminators.” “Arena.” “Seedpeople.”

In “Eliminators,” a scientist builds this cyborg named John T. Mandroid. Mandroid seeks revenge for the death of his father — that’s the premise. And the thing takes place in a generic Amazon-esque jungle location. And here’s how I sum it up: When John T. Mandroid is about to set off on his mission, he turns to Denise Crosby and says, “I’ll need my mobile unit.” Smash cut to John T. Mandroid now in his mobile unit — his torso connected to a set of caterpillar treads.

When you are a kid, you might find these movies by chance at the store. Then you buy a tape and watch it a bunch of times. That’s part of what was special about physical media before Netflix. You have the item in your house and the lack of so many options means you end up playing it over and over.

 

GC: Tell me about your podcast.

AS: My partner Ryan Roe and I co-host “Movin’ Right Along: A Muppet Movie Podcast.” Our podcast shamelessly borrows the basic format of “Star Wars Minute.” We watch and discuss the Muppet movies two minutes at a time. We’ve been at it for a little over three years and have made it through three films: “The Muppet Movie,” “The Great Muppet Caper,” and “The Muppets Take Manhattan.” Each episode is around a half hour.

We’ve had some great guests. Brian Jay Jones, author of “Jim Henson: The Biography.” Michael Frith, former Executive Vice-President and Creative Director of The Jim Henson Company. This is the guy who designed Uncle Deadly and Fozzie, among many others.

Frith also designed the Muppet Babies for “The Muppets Take Manhattan.” He was a liaison to the later Muppet Babies cartoon. His appearance on our show was to focus specifically on the Muppet Babies.

We’ve had several Henson puppeteers on the show, including Leslie Carrara-Rudolph, who plays Abby Cadabby, and longtime performer Andy Hayward. Pop culture writers, too. Will Harris and Noel Murray and Erik Adams from “The A.V. Club.”

 

GC: Who is your favorite Muppet?

AS: Ernie. Always. This is a guy who has many songs exploring his own intellectual curiosity about the world. “I Don’t Want to Live on the Moon.” “I Wonder.” “Imagine That.” Ernie’s inner life is thoughtful and introspective. But Ernie’s outer life sees him playing savage tricks on his roommate, like stealing his nose. I can relate to that.

 

GC: Well, I’m a total Bert. I was able to recognize that even when I was watching “Sesame Street” in the 1970s. I grew up and married an Ernie. So far, it has worked out.

AS: Great! Can I say one more thing?

CM with AS 2 (2021)

GC: Please.

AS: During the height of DVDs, I would go out and buy any movie I saw and liked. Especially because so many of the DVDs had fantastic bonus features. I think about that a lot. I have so much nostalgia for the days when you could walk into Best Buy — which today mostly sells Bluetooth speakers and refrigerators — and find the Warner Bros. Pictures Gangsters Collection Vol. 1. It contained six movies: “The Petrified Forest,” “The Public Enemy,” “Little Caesar,” “Angels with Dirty Faces,” “The Roaring Twenties” and “White Heat.” Zero clunkers in the set. And all of them had audio commentaries, documentaries, Maltin introductions, cartoons from the feature’s release year, live action short subjects, trailers, and newsreels.

Well, I didn’t know then how good I had it.

The Many Saints of Newark

HPR Many Saints of Newark (2021)

Movie review by Greg Carlson

I love “The Sopranos.”

I have spent many hours with the show, re-watching favorite episodes, reading popular and academic books and essays deconstructing the series, queuing up clip playlists on YouTube to numb the pain of months in pandemic-imposed isolation. Like many others for whom David Chase’s vivid universe is “our thing,” I awaited “The Many Saints of Newark” with an equal amount of excitement and trepidation. I hoped that it could open up a fresh chapter in mob movie mythology the way that Scorsese’s “Goodfellas” was an extension of the indelible marks made by Coppola in “The Godfather” and “The Godfather Part II.” I expected it would honor traditions stretching back to that early sound-era trinity of “Little Caesar,” “The Public Enemy,” and “Scarface.”

But I also knew going in that James Gandolfini would not be in the movie. And no matter how close the resemblance between Gandolfini and his son Michael, who plays the teenage version of Anthony John Soprano Sr., the odds were long that Chase and his collaborators would successfully recapture the right place/right time zeitgeist that spanned 1999 to 2007. Yes, “The Many Saints of Newark” walks and talks more like the pilot to a new season of HBO prequel content than a standalone feature, but given how often it was said that nearly any individual installment of “The Sopranos” was so good it felt like a self-contained movie, I choose to cut “Saints” a break.

The misleading marketing that suggested the film would focus primarily on Tony’s origin story didn’t do Chase any favors and has been — along with several applications of retroactive continuity (Silvio and Tony’s age gap? C’mon!) — a thorn in the movie’s side on fan message boards throughout the film’s opening weekend. “Saints” is narrated, “Our Town” and “Lincoln in the Bardo”-style, by the doomed Christopher Moltisanti (Michael Imperioli). Christopher’s father, Dickie Moltisanti (Alessandro Nivola) emerges as the film’s central character. True to Chase’s skill as a storyteller and his interest in mirrored and rhyming themes, Dickie is an intriguing mixture of both the Christopher and Tony of the original series.

Despite a variety of shortcomings that encompass eye-rolling fan-service lollipops and unresolved narrative threads, there is much to savor here. Chase’s interest in the dreamscapes of the unexplainable, the hallucinatory and the mystical, which manifested so strongly in wild side trips including “Funhouse” and “The Test Dream,” may or may not be hiding in plain sight with a provocative bit of classic soap opera evil-twinning that will catch fans who viewed the trailer completely off guard. The audacious device hints that Dickie’s desire to do good and to make amends for the unforgivable exists only in his imagination: “Maybe some of the things you do aren’t God’s favorite.”

With veteran collaborators Alan Taylor as director and Lawrence Konner as co-writer, Chase packs much, maybe even too much, into this particular tale. But I appreciated the many grace notes and blue notes that Chase always plays so well. Not unlike the arrival of Furio Giunta, the presence of Michela De Rossi’s Giuseppina deepens our understanding of the immigrant’s connections between the North Jersey DiMeo family and the romanticized Old Country. And Chase’s magic touch informs the way in which fate, chance, luck, and timing briefly suggest glimmers of hope for Tony — beautifully suggested by key moments in time like a shot at the end of the ice cream truck hijacking, the misinterpretation of the Elavil in Dickie’s pocket, and waiting in vain at Holsten’s.

Val

HPR Val (2021)

Movie review by Greg Carlson

Ting Poo and Leo Scott may be the directors of record, but “Val” unfolds almost purely as the kaleidoscopic personal diary of subject and writer Val Kilmer, the mercurial one-time superstar who has spent more time in recent years dealing with throat cancer than pursuing screen roles. Kilmer’s initial public denial of his diagnosis — which in retrospect seems entirely in keeping with his idiosyncratic approach to the line between the real and the performed — spawned both speculation and rumor. “Val” is striking for its intimacy and for its candor (at least as far as Kilmer’s current health goes). Kilmer now speaks on camera by covering the hole in his throat. His son Jack, in the first-person role of his father, provides the voiceover narration.

Near the beginning of the film, Kilmer declares that “I was the first guy I knew to own a video camera.” And even before he amassed thousands of hours of home movies and behind-the-scenes footage, he was expressing himself through wildly imaginative original short films and stage plays as a kid, often with his brothers Mark and Wesley. Kilmer’s artistic inclinations would lead him to Juilliard, where he was the youngest person at that time accepted into the Drama Division. At first, it seems like Kilmer leads a charmed and magical existence. Significant tragedy, however, waits in the wings.

Kilmer’s personal observations and insights are always engaging and occasionally yield details and particulars that allow viewers to peek behind the curtain of fame. Sober assessments of key portrayals are among the film’s highlights, and serve to remind us that once upon a time, Kilmer was an A-list force with Hollywood at his feet. He notes that, “Yes, every boy wants to be Batman. They actually want to be him. They don’t necessarily want to play him in a movie.” Certain characters require more time for Kilmer to unpack, but unsolicited audition tapes he made while pursuing “Full Metal Jacket” and “Goodfellas” are easily as fascinating as the way in which he prepared for Doc Holliday and Jim Morrison.

Even more affecting is Kilmer’s openness regarding the realities of making ends meet when lucrative marquee contracts are no longer an option. He says, “I’m selling, basically, my old self, my old career. For many people it’s like the lowest thing you can do is talk about your old pictures and sell photographs…” But to his credit, Kilmer refuses to speak ill of fellow actors who have resorted to the same convention circuit or of the fans who wait in line for hours to meet their idol.

Kilmer crossed paths with legends of different generations, but the sole occupant atop the throne of the Dream Factory’s Mount Olympus was Marlon Brando. The bizarre tale of the making of “The Island of Dr. Moreau,” one of the most dysfunctional studio-backed projects of the 1990s, is already the subject of David Gregory’s fascinating 2014 documentary “Lost Soul.” In “Val” we get a glimpse of Kilmer’s perspective on the debacle, riveting in its own smaller-scale way. As things quickly go off the rails, we share in Kilmer’s crushing disappointment.

The moviemaking stories are juicy, but the filmmakers also capitalize on the intimacy of Kilmer’s family saga, including portraits of father Eugene and mother Gladys (Kilmer’s parents split when he was eight years old). Kilmer’s marriage to and divorce from Joanne Whalley is handled with more respect and fewer fireworks than many of the backstage anecdotes. Along with Jack, daughter Mercedes also appears in the film. Both children dote on their dad, who concludes this scrapbook with the signature self-confidence and optimism that fueled his meteoric career.

Kid 90

HPR Kid 90 (2021)

Movie review by Greg Carlson

Equally frustrating and fascinating, Soleil Moon Frye’s quasi-confessional nostalgia documentary “Kid 90” will attract pop culture consumers of a certain age lured by the promise of pre-internet home movies and video diaries capturing an astonishing number of young performers before, during, and in some cases at the peaks of their fame. Frye is still best known for headlining the NBC sitcom “Punky Brewster,” which debuted in 1984 when she was just eight years old. By the time she was a teen, Frye was shooting footage of her life and her interactions with an array of fellow dream factory aspirants.

As director/compiler/star, Frye is careful to withhold any clips that could potentially damage her own brand or the images of her fellow Hollywood peers. One of the film’s executive producers is Leonardo DiCaprio, whose own fleeting presence in “Kid 90” is limited to the period of time before he embarked on the decidedly politically incorrect, pre-Me Too shenanigans that saw his circle of pals coarsely dubbed the “Pussy Posse.” Frye makes no mention of that specific pack of brats, even though a number of “Don’s Plum” alumni, including Kevin Connolly, Jenny Lewis, and Heather McComb are among those in Frye’s orbit.

There is some level at which “Kid 90” circles the ethical dilemmas faced for decades by professional child actors, their youth exploited and their innocence shredded in the teeth of the entertainment industry that has elevated profit above welfare since Jackie Coogan became a poster boy for mistreated minors. By all accounts, Frye’s own mother was perceived by her daughter and her daughter’s friends as a nurturing, supportive presence. Frye’s father, the actor Virgil Frye, is the subject of her 2004 documentary “Sonny Boy” and was not always around (something “Kid 90” mentions more than once).

“Kid 90” includes as one major thread the unacceptable number of young lives cut short in Frye’s community of friends and acquaintances, but as Inkoo Kang so astutely put it, the movie “is conspicuously incurious about the systemic factors that may have contributed to their deaths, such as financial and familial pressure, addiction, sexual trauma and other mental health struggles.” Or, for that matter, the nature of the industry in which they labored. Instead, there is a small measure of Frye’s own perspective as a grown-up, many years later.

Frye speaks about her personal experience with sexual assault, but as director also makes it clear that the movie’s “dark side” material will avoid any investigation of predatory practices or men who coerced vulnerable girls and women. And even though Frye’s aim is to find some kind of balance between the draw of fans getting glimpses of their favorite stars and a kind of public processing of her own grief and loss, the new interviews skew almost entirely male — Brian Austin Green, Balthazar Getty, David Arquette, Mark-Paul Gosselaar, Daniel “Danny Boy” O’Connor, Perry Farrell, and Stephen Dorff all get more time than McComb.

In “Singin’ in the Rain,” Jean Hagen’s Lina Lamont famously notes, “If we bring a little joy into your humdrum lives, it makes us feel as though our hard work ain’t been in vain for nothin’.” The comment continues to speak volumes about the gulf between wealthy celebrities and us common folk. Frye, who has continued to thrive as a performer, voice actor, entrepreneur, filmmaker, author, web series host, and parent, is savvy enough to recognize her position of privilege. Even so, “Kid 90” is a story that could have used more unguarded introspection.

Remembering Matt Myers

George Romero w MM 2

Reflection by Greg Carlson

Matt Myers died unexpectedly on August 20 while exploring Iceland with Dr. Jacqueline Bussie, his partner of 38 years.

We are still trying, without success, to make sense of it.

His large circle, which touched both coasts and for the last decade met in the middle in Fargo, North Dakota, mourns his loss. Like many, I received the terrible news in a state of stunned disbelief. Matt had an appetite for life, for love, for creativity, for adventure, for movies, for the future, and most of all for Jacqueline that was so large it negated anything as unthinkable as his absence from this world. He had been practicing his craft for a long time but in so many ways was just getting started.

It was a stroke of good fortune that Jacqueline and Matt found a house in the 1100 block of 8th Street when they arrived in 2011. My family lived on 7th, and the close proximity meant just a two or three minute walk, door to door. As Jacqueline settled into her role at Concordia College, where I teach film and media courses, Matt befriended me and we bonded over our mutual admiration for movies big and small, new and old, weird and weirder. When he learned I had never seen his friend Richard Elfman’s “Forbidden Zone” (Matt was executive producing the sequel), he immediately gave me a copy.

Matt’s fondness for Halloween manifested in unbridled enthusiasm for neighborhood trick or treaters, prize-worthy decorations (including Norman Bates’s dear mother in an upper window), and his elaborate, camera-ready costumes. You could count on him to make every October 31 sweeter than the last as he greeted little witches, ghosts, and goblins with an ear-to-ear grin and a cauldron of candy. One year he was every inch Bela Lugosi’s Count Dracula, complete with fangs, cape, and star-shaped sunburst medallion. Adam West’s 1966 Batman was another perfect choice. My favorite, however, replicated the bandages and dark glasses illusion of the Claude Rains Invisible Man as he (dis)appeared in 1933.

In her touching tribute to Matt, Jacqueline wrote that his “love language was food.” Anyone who had the pleasure of tasting Matt’s cuisine knows that he could have been a world-class chef or restaurateur had he not loved making movies so much. I sat at Matt and Jacqueline’s table several times and still can’t tell you what was more fantastic: the food or Matt’s determination to do special things right here, like the independent feature filmmaking of Joe Maggio’s “Supermoto” or an advance screening of Stefon Bristol’s “See You Yesterday.”

Matt’s gift for making connections was substantial. As a producer, he valued results and big picture thinking. The Fargo Film Festival owes him debts of gratitude for facilitating several unforgettable events. Matt brought Hal Hartley and John Waters to the stage of the Fargo Theatre. And when George Romero politely declined our invitation to travel from Toronto to Fargo — health considerations prevented the journey — we hatched a plan with Fargo Film Festival Executive Director Emily Beck to take the party to Canada to present the Ted M. Larson Award, the festival’s highest honor.

George Romero w MM 1 (1)

Matt made all the arrangements. George Romero agreed to record a short greeting that would be shown during the festival in lieu of an in-person acceptance. The night before the appointment, Matt McGregor and I were walking on Yonge Street when I received a call from Matt.

“What are you doing?”

“Just wandering around. What’s up?”

“George would like you to join us for dinner.”

After I picked up my jaw, we hurried to Romero’s apartment to embark on what would turn into a two-day audience with the legendary filmmaker. Matt was under no obligation to invite me and McGregor that evening, but his largesse and spirit of inclusion resulted in one of my most cherished experiences. Matt transformed what I thought would be a brief and somewhat formal interaction into an intimate, freewheeling conversation that stretched across hours. There were cigars. There was whiskey.

I have taken comfort in the words of Matt’s friends as they have expressed condolences to Jacqueline through social media. I have learned more about Matt as a mentor, a teacher, a collaborator, a dreamer. Many have remarked on his generosity, his brilliant sense of humor, his joie de vivre, and his sharp intelligence. But my own favorite quality was his fierce devotion to Jacqueline. It is, after all, what brought him to Fargo in the first place.

+++++

Jacqueline’s friends have set up a GoFundMe page to assist with the significant medical and legal costs incurred by a death abroad. Any gifts in excess of those costs will be donated to ELCA World Hunger, the primary charity Matt designated in his will. https://gofund.me/e50d7af0

HPR Matt Myers Jacqueline (2021)

For Madmen Only: The Stories of Del Close

HPR For Madmen Only (2021)

Movie review by Greg Carlson

Filmmaker Heather Ross combines a variety of striking visuals — including creative nonfiction reenactments, animated comic book panels and collages, archival stills and film clips, vintage stock footage, and conventional talking heads — to assemble “For Madmen Only: The Stories of Del Close.” Described by Bill Murray and others as “the most famous person you’ve never heard of,” Close was the monumentally influential mentor who counted dozens of comic powerhouses among his students. Close was also one of the early practitioners to recognize long-form improvisational performance as an art in and of itself. He died of emphysema on March 4, 1999, just a few days shy of his 65th birthday.

Ross is not the first person to document the Del Close phenomenon, but “For Madmen Only” covers an impressive amount of historical and spiritual territory in just under an hour and a half without ever suggesting that significant milestones were ignored or excised. Close fanatics might quibble over the real estate afforded one thing or another (the sections devoted to Close, played by James Urbaniak, working on some of the twisted autobiographical material that would end up in the DC comic “Wasteland” would be better in slightly smaller doses). But one has to admire the way in which Ross honors her subject by devising something as willing to take risks as the guru himself.

The “who’s who” of talent in interviews new and old undoubtedly presented Ross with a nearly endless supply of tough choices. And despite the late critical aside that Close had a tendency to favor white boys — who are thoroughly represented in the movie — the lineup also includes key input from Tim Meadows, Amy Poehler, Tina Fey, and others. Arguably, the most important on-camera subject to speak with authority on Close is Charna Halpern, the collaborator, partner, and ImprovOlympic cofounder who perhaps best understood his unique gifts and harnessed and honed the Harold concept into the version most fully appreciated by audiences.

Given the vault of stories focused on Close’s prodigious appetite for smoking, drinking, and drug-taking, Ross elects to maintain a kind of balance between the man’s most magnificent impulses in the direction of generosity and humanity (evident in Close’s belief that the tools and techniques of improv could be taught to any willing student and not just sublime natural talents like John Belushi and Gilda Radner) and his darker moments. Even though he would come to embrace his role as sage bestower of comedic wisdom in the laboratory setting, the movie does suggest that Close experienced significant frustrations throughout his career.

The first of these professional potholes involves the jaw-dropping tale of Close’s membership in the Compass Players, his romance with Elaine May, and the insult of being left out when May and fellow Compass performer Mike Nichols decided to do their own thing after making it to New York. Close’s rocky yet indelible relationship with Chicago and Second City follows, and Ross shows the emerging pattern.

Undoubtedly, “For Madmen Only” is essential viewing for comedy and improvisation hounds, but Ross must be praised for her ability to appeal to general audiences as well as hardcore scholars. In their valuable 2012 “Studies in American Humor” article on Close, Diana DePasquale and Melinda M. Lewis wrote, “As with any great teacher, it is impossible to quantify Close’s impact with finality, as it continues to permeate culture and entertainment.” Thanks to Ross’s film, Close’s legacy will reach the next generation of performers-to-be.

Plan B

HPR Plan B (2021)

Movie review by Greg Carlson

Busy performer Natalie Morales makes her solo feature directorial debut with the winning road trip teen comedy “Plan B.” Equally raucous and heartfelt, the movie follows in the footsteps of Olivia Wilde’s influential “Booksmart” by focusing on the relationship of two close high school friends. And not unlike the frequently-discussed phenomenon sometimes called “twin films,” (like “Dante’s Peak” and “Volcano” in 1997, “Capote” and “Infamous” in 2006, and “Friends with Benefits” and “No Strings Attached” in 2011, to name just a few) “Plan B” shares enough striking similarities to Rachel Lee Goldenberg’s “Unpregnant” that “Decider” and “Salon” articles have pondered the recent emergence of so-called “reproductive rights road films.”

Syracuse, New York stands in for South Dakota, but the escalating complications requiring the protagonists to get in the van are universal enough to take place in just about Anytown, U.S.A. Kuhoo Verma’s Sunny, eager for some kind of carnal experience, makes a hasty and questionable choice while hosting an impromptu house party while her real estate agent mom is out of town on business. Instead of hooking up with crush Hunter (Michael Provost) as planned, Sunny impulsively has sex with devout Christian goofball Kyle (Mason Cook). Sunny’s best pal Lupe (Victoria Moroles) — who does not know about the boy switch — supports Sunny when a condom mishap necessitates a wild goose chase after an emergency contraceptive pill.

Even while marking the checklist of outrageous teen movie tropes revolving around awkward predicaments, mind-altering substances, lies told to oneself and lies told to others, hasty escapes, embarrassing sexual encounters, and the multitude of liminal passages en route to hard-earned maturity, Morales consistently seeks out the pathos and humanity of her leads. Some of the obstacles are less convincing than others (a diversion involving a temporarily stolen vehicle strains the film’s already elastic internal logic). But Morales works several small miracles in moments that allow supporting characters to surprise us.

Screenwriters Prathiksha Srinivasan and Joshua Levy maintain a close watch on the emotional growth of the principal partners. As a result, “Plan B” is a rare bird in that it gets better as it goes along. So many movies in the teensploitation tradition start strong and quickly run out of gas. It is also true that many films in the genre turn authority figures, parents, and all other grown-ups into caricatures, but Sunny’s mother and Lupe’s father reveal nuances in the parent/child dynamic that transcend the surface gags (although the running “Indian mafia” joke is pretty solid) to at least briefly answer the age-old question, “Are parents people?”

Along with the worry and concern that nettle both Sunny and Lupe when it comes to their fears regarding possible parental reactions, “Plan B” also takes seriously the themes of bodily autonomy, female health and wellness, and the politically-driven mechanisms in place in states like South Dakota that seek to regulate and control women. Kylie Cheung cites a trio of other recent movies, including “Grandma,” “Little Woods,” and “Never Rarely Sometimes Always,” noting that “..while growth and improving representation of abortion and reproductive care in media is a victory, it’s a victory that’s hard to celebrate when the dehumanizing, real-life conditions upon which these movies are based shouldn’t exist at all.” It seems improbable that the need for stories like the one told in “Plan B” will go away anytime soon.