Movie review by Greg Carlson
Filmmaker James Gray pays homage to classic NYC crime sagas with “Paper Tiger,” a satisfying family melodrama featuring the formidable trio of Scarlett Johansson, Adam Driver and Miles Teller. Set in 1986, the movie traces the cascade of misfortune visited upon Pearl brothers Gary (Driver) and Irwin (Teller) as their plan to make some easy – if not strictly legal – income runs afoul of Russian mobsters. Gary, a well-connected “security consultant” and former cop retired from the NYPD, convinces civilian Irwin to contribute his engineering expertise in a dubious deal involving the Gowanus Canal. In the meantime, Irwin’s wife Hester (Johansson), the watchful and devoted mother of their sons Scott (Gavin Goudey) and Ben (Roman Engel), faces a potentially devastating health issue.
Gray’s literate/literary sensibilities and commitment to classic dramatic structure and unity have marked an intriguing filmography beginning with debut “Little Odessa” in 1994. “Paper Tiger” is as good as any of the director’s films, which include the Dostoevsky-spinning “Two Lovers” and the metaphysical science fiction “Ad Astra.” Gray, who has never developed the widespread following of any number of his auteur peers, is in some ways overdue for the kind of critical adoration heaped upon several contemporaries. A graduate of the USC School of Cinematic Arts, Gray excels at the kind of keenly observed portraits made by fellow alum James Foley.
Both Gray and Foley know how to place character at the heart of the narrative, even when adhering to the narrative and genre expectations of what might be, in less capable hands, stereotypes of crooked cops, ruthless gangsters and hapless family men unfamiliar with violence. Gray stages several wholly engrossing sequences of creeping dread and malevolent suspense, including a gripping, late-night home invasion that tests Irwin and Hester by underlining the extent to which they have been keeping secrets from one another. Darkness is coming in more ways than one.
Like many of Gray’s movies, “Paper Tiger” blends together large-canvas tragedy with the intimate familiarity of our own interpersonal relationships. Drawing from Greek drama and Shakespeare, the filmmaker utilizes fate and circumstance and something that might be bad luck to snare the attention of the viewer as the screws are methodically tightened. Irwin’s desire to impress his sons unintentionally places his loved ones in harm’s way. Gary, in his quest to rectify the situation, will quickly come to realize that he may not have the resources to extract himself and his brother from mortal danger.
Hinting at the contrasts that define siblings from the book of Genesis to “The Brothers Karamazov” to “East of Eden,” Gray masterfully communicates the many ways that Gary and Irwin simultaneously love and resent one another; each one has something the other desperately lacks and longingly covets. It’s also a delicious bit of casting that reunites incendiary “Marriage Story” castmates Johansson and Driver, suggesting a parallel world in which Hester might have chosen the flashier and self-confident Gary over the stable but less thrilling Irwin. As “Paper Tiger” unfolds on the way to its gripping conclusion, Gray reveals that Hester is every bit as important and central to the tale as the Pearl brothers.
